7 min read

Classrooms Without Walls: How Mentorship Is Closing the Learning Gap

Seven in ten 10-year-olds in poorer countries can’t read a simple text. Here is what the evidence says mentors can do about it.

A woman speaks with a group of secondary school students in Nigeria, mentorship that helps in closing the learning gap
Photo by Emmanuel Ikwuegbu on Unsplash

A child can sit in a classroom every day for four years and still not be able to read a simple story. That quiet gap between attending school and actually learning is one of the largest challenges in education today. The encouraging news is that some of the most effective ways of closing the learning gap are surprisingly human: a patient adult, a small group, a regular time to meet.

This post looks at what the evidence says about mentorship and tutoring, why girls’ education deserves special attention, and how phones and laptops are turning ordinary homes into classrooms without walls.

What “learning poverty” really means

The World Bank uses the term learning poverty for the share of 10-year-olds who cannot read and understand a simple written text. It is a blunt measure on purpose. Reading with understanding by around age ten is the foundation for almost everything that follows, from mathematics word problems to health leaflets to job applications.

According to the World Bank’s State of Global Learning Poverty: 2022 Update, an estimated 70 percent of 10-year-olds in low- and middle-income countries were in learning poverty, up from 57 percent before the pandemic. The picture varies sharply by region.

Behind each percentage is a child who is trying. Many are in school, many have dedicated teachers, and many families are making real sacrifices. The gap is rarely about effort; it is usually about attention. Classes of sixty or more, a curriculum that races ahead of where children actually are, and too few books at home all add up. What would change if every struggling reader had one adult who knew exactly where they were stuck?

Why girls’ education needs a closer look

Progress for girls has been real. UNESCO reports that 50 million more girls have enrolled in school globally since 2015. Yet the same data shows that 122 million girls are still out of school around the world.

For girls who are enrolled, the barriers can be quieter: household duties that cut into study time, long or unsafe journeys, early marriage, or simply the absence of a woman in their lives who has walked the path they hope to walk. This is where mentorship becomes more than tutoring. A mentor shows a girl what is possible, helps her plan the next step and encourages her family to see her education as an investment worth protecting.

Think of the person who first made you believe you could do something difficult. Did they teach you a skill, or did they simply expect more of you than you expected of yourself? Often it is both.

What the evidence says about tutoring and mentoring

A teacher sits beside a young student and helps with maths homework at a classroom desk
Photo by Vitaly Gariev on Unsplash

Tutoring is one of the most rigorously studied tools in education. A J-PAL evidence review of 96 randomized evaluations, summarizing a meta-analysis by Nickow, Oreopoulos and Quan, found an overall effect of 0.37 standard deviations. In plain terms, that is roughly enough to move a typical student from the 50th percentile to near the 66th.

The details matter as much as the headline. Most of the studies come from high-income countries, so they are a guide rather than a guarantee elsewhere, but the patterns are instructive:

  • Training counts. Programmes led by teachers (0.50) and trained paraprofessionals (0.40) outperformed those run by untrained volunteers (0.21) or parents (0.23).
  • Timing counts. Tutoring during the school day (0.40) did better than after-school sessions (0.21), partly because sessions were more likely to actually happen.
  • Early years count. Reading support had its largest effects in the earliest grades, while maths tutoring stayed strong into the later primary years.

This is not a reason for volunteers to step back. The same review notes that volunteer tutoring remains promising because it is low-cost and widely accessible. It is a reason to train, structure and support every volunteer mentor, rather than simply matching a kind adult with a child and hoping for the best.

Teaching at the right level

A recurring idea in this research is meeting children where they are, not where the textbook assumes they should be. A ten-year-old who cannot yet decode words gains little from a grade-five comprehension exercise. Short assessments, small groups sorted by current level and simple, repeated practice tend to work better than racing through the syllabus. Mentors who understand this can do in a few focused sessions what months of mismatched lessons cannot.

Classrooms without walls: phones, laptops and low-tech learning

A young woman wearing headphones studies at a desk, learning remotely
Photo by Julio Lopez on Unsplash

Digital learning is often imagined as tablets and high-speed connections. Some of the most striking results, however, have come from the simplest technology available: a basic mobile phone.

During school closures in Botswana, a randomized trial published in Nature Human Behaviour (Angrist, Bergman and Matsheng, 2022) tested short weekly phone calls plus text messages to families. The combination improved learning by 0.12 standard deviations and reduced absolute innumeracy, meaning children unable to do any basic operations, by 31 percent. Text messages alone did not have a significant effect. The human voice on the other end of the line made the difference. The authors also found the approach ranked among the most cost-effective ways to improve learning.

That finding matters for anyone who wants to mentor from afar. Remote mentoring works best when it is:

  • Low-bandwidth by design. A voice call or messaging app reaches far more families than a video platform.
  • Regular and short. Fifteen to twenty minutes at the same time each week builds habit and trust.
  • Family-inclusive. Parents and older siblings become co-teachers when they are invited in.
  • Safe. Calls are arranged through a supervising organization, with clear safeguarding rules and no private contact outside agreed channels.

Which tools in your own pocket could become a classroom for someone else, if they were used with this much care?

What makes a good mentor

Good mentors are not necessarily the most qualified people in the room. They are reliable, curious and patient. They show up when they said they would, they ask more questions than they answer, and they celebrate small wins: the first sentence read aloud without help, the first fraction understood.

Mentoring across cultures adds a layer of responsibility. A mentor working with students in North Africa, South Asia or Sub-Saharan Africa should learn about local school calendars, languages of instruction and family expectations before offering advice. Our colleague’s guide to volunteering across cultures covers this in depth, and it is worth reading before you begin.

It also helps to remember that learning does not happen in isolation. A child who is hungry, unwell or walking hours for water has less energy for reading. That is why education sits alongside water, food, health and shelter in our thinking, as explored in Water First.

How Jamila Charity approaches learning

Learning is one of the four programme areas Jamila Charity is preparing, alongside Water & Food, Health & Care, and Shelter & Relief. Because we are still in formation, we are taking the time to design it around what the evidence supports: trained mentors, structured sessions, low-tech tools that reach families where they are, and partnerships led by local educators.

We will not publish impact claims before there is impact to report. When our learning work begins, we will share what we measure and how, on our Our Work page and in our transparency updates. Until then, the best thing many readers can offer is their interest, their skills and their patience.

Frequently asked questions

What is learning poverty?

Learning poverty is a World Bank measure of the share of 10-year-olds who cannot read and understand a simple written text. It combines children who are out of school with those in school who have not yet learned to read with comprehension. The World Bank estimated it at 70 percent across low- and middle-income countries in 2022.

What does “closing the learning gap” mean?

The learning gap is the difference between what children are expected to know at their age and what they actually know. Closing it means helping children catch up on foundational skills, especially reading and basic maths, so they can benefit from the rest of their schooling. Targeted tutoring and teaching at the right level are among the best-evidenced approaches.

Does volunteer tutoring actually work?

Yes, though trained tutors tend to achieve more. In the J-PAL review of 96 randomized evaluations, volunteer tutoring showed a positive effect of 0.21 standard deviations, compared with 0.40 for trained paraprofessionals and 0.50 for teachers. Training, structure and regular scheduling help volunteers get closer to those stronger results.

What is the difference between tutoring and mentoring?

Tutoring focuses on specific academic skills, such as reading fluency or fractions, usually through structured sessions. Mentoring is broader: it includes guidance, encouragement, goal-setting and helping a young person navigate choices. The strongest programmes often combine both, especially for girls and first-generation learners.

Can mentoring by phone really improve learning?

A randomized trial in Botswana, published in Nature Human Behaviour in 2022, found that short weekly phone calls combined with text messages improved learning by 0.12 standard deviations and cut absolute innumeracy by 31 percent. Text messages alone had no significant effect. The live conversation appears to be what matters.

How many girls are out of school worldwide?

UNESCO reports that 122 million girls are still out of school around the world, even though 50 million more girls have enrolled since 2015. Girls who are enrolled can also face barriers to learning, such as household duties, long journeys and early marriage. Mentoring can help girls and their families keep education on track.

How can I become an education mentor with Jamila Charity?

Jamila Charity is still in formation, and our Learning programme is being designed with care before volunteer roles open. You can register your interest on our Get Involved page and tell us about your skills and languages. We will contact you as structured, safeguarded mentoring roles become available.

From Jamila Charity

Be the patient adult a learner needs

We are preparing a Learning programme built on trained, supported mentors and low-tech tools that reach families where they are. Register your interest and tell us what you could teach.

Around the web

Giving resources and our partner network

Disclosure: WebTailor, Tailor Themes, AskConfy, Norvic, MotorIQ and AuctionCalc are part of the same family of sites as Jamila Charity. No listing on this page is paid.

Pledge now, give when we’re ready

One beautiful act starts the ripple.

Jamila Charity is preparing to register. Pledge what you’d like to give today. Nothing is charged, and we’ll write to you the moment giving opens.